publication . Article . 2019

Comparative Hagiology and/as Manuscript Studies: Method and Materiality

Barbara Zimbalist;
Open Access English
  • Published: 31 Oct 2019 Journal: Religions (issn: 2077-1444, Copyright policy)
  • Publisher: Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute
1270), I suggest that comparative material research into the textual history of hagiographic literature can provide us with a more comprehensive and nuanced picture of the production of any specific holy figure, as well as the evolving discourses of sanctity and holiness in general. While this suggestion emerges from my own work on medieval hagiography from the Christian Latin West, it resonates with recent arguments by Sara Ritchey and David DiValerio to call for a materially comparative approach to narratives of holy lives in any religious tradition in any time period. Furthermore, I suggest that medieval studies, and in particular medieval manuscript studies, may have much to offer to scholars of sanctity working in later periods and other settings. Offering a view of material textual scholarship as intrinsically comparative, we may expand our theoretical definitions of the comparative and its possibilities within the study of sanctity.
Although the academic study of hagiography continues to flourish, the role of comparative methods within the study of sanctity and the saints remains underutilized. Similarly, while much valuable work on saints and sanctity relies on materialist methodologies, issues of critical bibliography particular to the study of hagiography have not received the theoretical attention they deserve. This essay takes up these two underattended approaches to argue for a comparative materialist approach to hagiography. Through a short case study of the Latin Vita of Lutgard of Aywi&egrave
1246) written by the Dominican friar Thomas of Cantimpr&eacute
res (1182&ndash
(c. 1200&ndash
Persistent Identifiers
Fields of Science and Technology classification (FOS)
06 humanities and the arts, 0601 history and archaeology, 060101 anthropology, 0603 philosophy, ethics and religion
Sustainable Development Goals (SDG)
16. Peace & justice
free text keywords: comparative literature, comparative method, comparative religions, critical bibliography, hagiography, hagiology, manuscript studies, medieval Christianity, religious studies, sainthood, lcsh:Religions. Mythology. Rationalism, lcsh:BL1-2790, Comparative literature, Medieval studies, Textual scholarship, History, Narrative, Classics, Materialism, Materiality (law)
  • Digital Humanities and Cultural Heritage
  • Social Science and Humanities
Download fromView all 3 versions
Open Access
Article . 2019
Providers: DOAJ-Articles
Open Access
Other literature type . Article . 2019
Open Access
Providers: UnpayWall
Any information missing or wrong?Report an Issue